Is Form Substance When it Comes to Law? Future of the Doctrines of Economic Substance & Substance Over Form

For instance, if a company delivers a product but retains significant risks and rewards of ownership, revenue recognition would be deferred until those risks and rewards are also transferred to the buyer. This ensures that the revenue reported in the financial statements aligns with the actual economic benefits realized by the company. Financial reporting is not just a statutory exercise; it is a communication tool that conveys the financial performance and position of a company to its stakeholders. The Substance Over Form principle is crucial in this context as it ensures that the reported figures are not just legally correct but also economically accurate.

Substance Over Form in GAAP and IFRS

This principle ensures that the financial statements reflect the true nature of the transactions and events, providing a more accurate representation of a company’s financial position and performance, which enhances the reliability and relevance of accounting information. Lease accounting is another area where the Substance Over Form principle has a profound impact. The principle has led to significant changes in how leases are reported on the balance sheet, particularly with the introduction of IFRS 16, “Leases.” Prior to IFRS 16, many leases were classified as operating leases and were not recognized on the balance sheet. However, IFRS 16 requires lessees to recognize most leases on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a corresponding lease liability. This change ensures that the company’s financial statements reflect the economic reality of the obligation to make lease payments and the right to use the underlying asset for a period of time.

Intermediate Financial Accounting I

This convention is based on the premise that the economic reality of a transaction is more important than its legal form. Substance over form in accounting refers to a concept that transactions recorded in the financial statements and accompanying disclosures of a company must reflect their economic substance rather than their legal form. Substance over form concept is an accounting technique that is more focused on the underlying factor and genuine intent and reality of a financial transaction rather than just recording or labeling it with a transactional name like rent, sale, purchase, lease, etc. In a nutshell, this accounting principle is more focused on the true nature of the transaction and not just the legal form that could be used to mislead the company’s readers and investors. The simple concept is that the company accounts should show what it has really earned along with what it owes and owns rather than just calculations that are formally and legally correct. For example, if a company sells a piece of equipment for cash, the transaction should be recorded as a sale even if the contract stipulates that the buyer will make monthly payments.

Examples of Substance Over Form

At the same time, though, the Sixth Circuit proceedings were one of three related appeals from the underlying case, all of which were appealed to different circuit courts. If they do not adopt the Sixth Circuit’s view, there will be a clear circuit split (if there is not already), which could make the issue ripe for the Supreme Court to weigh in. The Code, a sprawling collection of more than 4 million “carefully”  placed words—words that are supplemented, of course, by even more voluminous regulations, rulings, and various administrative authorities—is obviously designed to raise revenue. But it is also designed to incentivize certain behavior, generally by decreasing taxes or providing other beneficial treatment. The Code is, in other words, a policy instrument, and it provides for many tax-based incentives.

Substance Over Form in Accounting

By recording the lease in this way, the company’s financial statements will better reflect the true economic nature of the transaction. While the principle of substance over form is typically used in complex financial situations, it can also be applied to more mundane transactions. In accordance with the terms of the lease agreement, the jets remain in ownership of DEF, Inc. throughout the lease term so the legal form of the contract/agreement dictates that ABC, Inc. should not record them as asset on its balance sheet.

• The Substance Over Form principle dictates that the financial statements and other accounting records should reflect the underlying economic reality of transactions, rather than merely their legal form.
• Substance over form is very subjective in some countries where they use rule base accounting (e.g. GAAP).
• Although the legal form can be of importance, it may be disregarded in order to present more relevant knowledge to the users of financial statements, who should not be misled.
• Though this approach may require more work upfront, it can help to provide a more accurate picture of a company’s financial position.
• The huge balance of cash on hand remains the same for several months before it was deposited back to bank right before the year-end.

Related AccountingTools Courses

Conversely, International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) are more principles-based, so it is more difficult for someone to justifiably hide the intent of a transaction if they are using the IFRS framework to construct financial statements. These adjustments are particularly relevant when analysts perform comparative analysis across firms or industries. By standardizing financial statements in accordance with the Substance Over Form principle, analysts can make more meaningful comparisons, as they ensure that the figures being compared are based on similar economic circumstances rather than disparate accounting treatments. This level of scrutiny allows for a more accurate assessment of a company’s performance, risk, and valuation. Substance over form is an accounting principle which recognizes that business transactions should be accounted in accordance with their (economic) substance instead of their (legal) form. Economic substance refers to the underlying economic or commercial purpose of a business transaction apart from its legal or tax considerations.

It involves complete disclosure and aims to reveal the genuine intent of transactions. Since this 1935 case, the doctrine of substance over form has dictated that taxpayers must abide by the economic substance of a transaction even if that substance is inconsistent with its legal form. The government started utilizing this doctrine to rectify situations where the taxpayer has willfully misrepresented a transaction in order to derive a tax benefit. Substance over form principle is recognized by all major financial reporting frameworks, namely the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and US GAAP, etc.

Substance over form is an accounting principle used “to ensure that financial statements give a complete, relevant, and accurate picture of transactions and events”. It is particularly relevant in cases of revenue recognition, sale and purchase agreements, etc. The key point of the concept is that a transaction should not be recorded in such a manner as to hide the true intent of the transaction, which would mislead the readers of a company’s financial statements. Substance over form is a fundamental accounting principle that emphasizes the economic reality of transactions rather than their legal form.

This is particularly important for investors, creditors, and regulators who depend on these reports to make decisions. For example, if a company engages in sale and leaseback transactions, the principle would require the transaction to be reported explanation of certain schedule c expenses in a way that shows the company’s ongoing obligation to make lease payments, rather than simply recording it as a sale. This approach enhances the quality of financial information, fostering transparency and trust in the financial markets.